I don’t have a singer. I have quite a few of them.
Mateo, Julian, Tanguy, Luca, Gloria, Gina, Mabel and others have all passed through CF EMCEE songs. And then there is CF EMCEE himself: a cloned version of my own voice.
You might expect that one to be the default. It isn’t.
I’m casting.
A voice can be technically excellent and still be completely wrong for a song. Too young. Too polished. Too earnest. Too theatrical. Too much country in the phrasing. Not enough weight in the lower register. Sometimes there is nothing obviously wrong with it at all — I simply don’t believe the person telling the story.
And that matters more than vocal perfection.
The character comes first
When I work on a song, I gradually form an idea of who could plausibly be singing it.
Not necessarily their age, appearance or biography. More a character.
Would this person smile while delivering that line? Have they lived long enough to say it? Are they observing the story or caught inside it? Should they sound completely certain, slightly amused, weary, curious?
That changes the casting.
Mateo has worked particularly well for some of my observational songs. Julian can take a song somewhere quite different. Tanguy brought the right character to several of the more energetic tracks. A low female voice such as Mabel can completely change the attitude of a song that initially existed only as words on a page.
None of that makes one voice better than another.
It makes one voice better for that song.
What about my own voice?
Having a cloned version of my own voice added another possibility.
It is recognisably mine, but that doesn’t mean it automatically belongs in every CF EMCEE song. I treat it much as I treat the other voices: does this particular narrator need to sound like me?
Sometimes the answer is yes.
That gives the CF EMCEE voice a peculiar position in the cast. It is both more personal than the others and, creatively, subject to exactly the same test.
If Mateo tells the story better, Mateo gets the job.
The wrong singer changes the writing
Casting also feeds back into the song itself.
A line that looked perfectly natural on paper can suddenly sound pompous when one voice sings it. Another singer can make the same line sound intimate. A phrase may need shortening because the character I hear would never linger over it. Occasionally a voice reveals that I have written the song from the wrong emotional angle altogether.
So choosing the singer isn’t something that happens after the songwriting.
It becomes part of it.
That is one reason I often generate several versions even after the basic song is working. I’m not always searching for a better performance. Sometimes I’m still searching for the person who should be standing behind the microphone.
There is no single CF EMCEE voice
That suits the project.
CF EMCEE moves between road songs, science, history, absurd ideas, biographies, jazz, pop and things that are harder to classify. Forcing all of that through one recognisable singer — even my own — would make the catalogue more consistent.
It would also make it less interesting.
The continuity comes from somewhere else: the subjects I choose, the way I tell stories, the decisions I make and the way the catalogue fits together.
The singer is part of the cast.
Even when the singer happens to be me.
