Shifting Gears started with a very specific job to do on Miles & Stories. After the repair and recalibration of Back in Tune, I wanted Track 10 to get the journey moving properly again. Technically and mentally, things were back in order. The new song needed the energy of Windows Down, but with a different kind of confidence: less reckless, more assured.
My first instinct was to stay close to the musical language of Back in Tune and simply add more drive. I initially aimed around 123 BPM, between Windows Down at 119 and Wrong Turn, Right Day at 125. I tried tighter drums, more rhythmic guitar, Hammond, piano and eventually muted trumpet. The results were perfectly competent, but that became the problem. I kept listening and thinking: so what?
I started looking for something that could give the track its own identity. Marimba was tried as an unexpected rhythmic accent and rejected almost immediately because it simply clashed with the song. I experimented with an asymmetric groove, even explicitly asking for 7/8 verses moving into 4/4 choruses. That produced bizarrely short generations, including one of about eighteen seconds. Describing the off-kilter feeling rather than specifying the time signature worked better, but it still did not solve the underlying problem.
The real change came when I stopped equating Shifting Gears with higher speed. I reduced the tempo and started thinking about groove instead, using the rhythmic confidence of late-1970s records such as Stayin’ Alive and Tragedy as a reference point rather than trying to make another faster roots song. Around 117 BPM, with a strong bass-and-drum pocket, clipped guitar and a more sophisticated rhythmic feel, the song immediately became more interesting.
The lyrics also needed work. The first drafts had been written for a more conventional forward-driving roots arrangement, and several lines became awkward once the groove changed. I shortened phrases, removed unnecessary syllables and gave the vocal more room to sit inside the rhythm. I also made sure that the second half of each chorus changed rather than simply repeating itself.
At one point I wondered whether I was simply becoming too accustomed to the sound of my own productions. Changing voices helped test that. Luca had been the obvious connection with Back in Tune, but I also tried Luigi and Jim. Unexpectedly, I ended up with four genuinely good contenders — two with Jim, one with Luigi and one with Luca — something I had not encountered before on this project.
I briefly pushed the arrangement much further away from the album, experimenting with interlocking guitars, hand percussion and an almost Afrobeat-like rhythmic architecture. That finally went too far. The useful discovery was where the boundary lay: Shifting Gears needed to step outside the established Americana/indie vocabulary without sounding as though it had wandered onto another album.
By the later versions, including v15, v22, v26 and v27, the problem was no longer finding a good version but choosing between several of them. The long detour had done its job. I discovered that changing gear musically did not mean playing faster or adding another instrument; it meant changing the engine underneath the song.