I wanted the opening song of the Sol-3 survey to sound like a proper scientific report, but not like somebody reading a spreadsheet aloud. That distinction shaped almost every decision I made while developing Planet 3: Vital Statistics.
I started by checking the scientific details against NASA and other reference material. Accuracy mattered, but the numbers also had to be singable. Kilometres proved particularly troublesome, so I eventually switched to rounded imperial measurements. I also decided that the investigators would describe their observations in their own terms, avoiding familiar human expressions wherever possible.
The perspective needed careful handling. The investigators speak collectively as a survey team, and their institutional announcement became a separate spoken introduction: a low, slightly nasal male voice heard through an intercom. Mateo handles the actual singing. I wanted the contrast between administrative authority and musical storytelling without turning the whole thing into a novelty performance.
My first musical direction was restrained jazz swing, around 98 BPM, with upright bass, brushed drums, piano and jaw harp. The instrumentation appealed to me, particularly the jaw harp as a slightly unfamiliar acoustic colour. The results, however, were frustrating. Some phrases were stretched unnaturally, others felt squeezed into the measure, and the singing repeatedly stopped and started instead of flowing.
I experimented with increasingly detailed Suno instructions, including classical musical terms such as legato, crescendo and forte. They did not provide the precise control I wanted. Even a forceful instruction for the outro made little audible difference.
Eventually I went back to the lyrics. I examined syllable counts, natural stresses and phrase lengths, then rebuilt the verses around a more consistent rhythmic pattern. One small but revealing change was replacing “Just under eight thousand” with “Almost eight thousand”. Removing a syllable made the line noticeably easier to sing. I also tightened the choruses while preserving my rule that their second halves must change.
Next I abandoned jazz swing. Straight 4/4 acoustic pop improved the vocal delivery, but the music became too economical. I wanted more personality. A vintage scientific-documentary approach initially seemed promising, until the results veered into comedy-caper territory. Worse, the running time collapsed from roughly 4:30 to 2:50. I had solved one problem by creating another.
The breakthrough came when I stopped trying to make every second vocally efficient. I slowed the arrangement to approximately 86 BPM, introduced an eight-bar instrumental opening and allowed short recurring piano-and-bass motifs between major sections. I simplified the prompts, removed unnecessary musical commands and gave the instruments room to contribute without interrupting the story.
Version 27 finally brought everything together. The music felt more spacious and subtly extraterrestrial, the jaw harp belonged naturally in the arrangement, and Mateo sounded unexpectedly darker in places. I kept him rather than changing singers. After comparing the remaining candidate, I selected v27 as the final version.
It took 27 versions to discover that the solution wasn’t more elaborate instructions or a more exotic sound. It was finding the right balance between the words, the rhythm and the space around them. Sometimes the music becomes more interesting when I stop trying to fill every available moment.