I started Dear Sam with the idea of writing a personal letter rather than a conventional tribute song. The challenge was to make it sound like a genuine conversation, not a history lesson or a collection of familiar phrases about an admired artist. I wanted the lyrics to be thoughtful, direct and conversational, with enough space for the music to breathe.
The writing took several rounds of revision. I expanded the structure to four verses, worked on the balance between the verses and choruses, and gradually removed lines that sounded too formal or predictable. Sometimes a single word made a difference. Waiting crowd became cheering crowd, and coming through became coming back. I also settled on The hour was his, the words were yours, a line that expressed exactly what I wanted without unnecessary explanation.
My first musical approach was a slow gospel-soul ballad, around 70 BPM in 6/8, with piano, Hammond organ, restrained drums and strings. On paper, it seemed appropriate. In practice, it repeatedly produced the wrong vocal performance. Suno kept pushing the singer towards powerful, demonstrative soul singing, with too much belting and emotional exaggeration.
I tried adjusting the prompts, raising the tempo slightly and specifying a quieter, more conversational delivery. The results improved in places, but the underlying problem remained. I was asking for the musical language of soul while trying to prevent the singer from adopting its more theatrical characteristics.
The breakthrough was to stop trying to make the song sound like Sam Cooke’s world. I decided that In Good Company needed its own musical identity. These songs would be letters to other artists, but they would sound like me.
I changed direction towards mature, piano-led European singer-songwriter music. The arrangement became more acoustic and understated, with upright bass, light brushed percussion and discreet cello. I moved to a regular 4/4 pulse and concentrated on creating a performance that felt natural rather than impressive.
One particularly interesting detail emerged in the finished recording: although the music feels relaxed and reflective, the actual tempo is approximately 130 BPM. The pulse is considerably faster than the listening experience suggests. That contrast works surprisingly well, giving the song forward movement without making it feel hurried.
I also used my own cloned CF EMCEE voice. That was an important decision. Instead of searching for a singer who could deliver the appropriate emotion, I could make the letter sound more personal, with a slightly rough, mature vocal character that suited the material. The objective was never vocal perfection. I wanted something believable.
Duration was another challenge. One version reached 6:03, prompting me to tighten the lyrics, particularly the choruses. Other versions came in around 5:00 and 4:35, but further attempts sometimes became longer again despite instructions to preserve the arrangement.
I eventually selected version 16, running 5:19. It wasn’t the shortest version, nor was every vocal phrase perfectly restrained. But the balance between voice, piano, arrangement and storytelling finally felt right.
Making Dear Sam taught me that musical restraint isn’t necessarily about slow tempos, sparse arrangements or perfectly controlled vocals. It’s about finding the performance that makes the words believable.