I started with a deliberately awkward musical challenge: could a sequence of unrelated words be made to feel like a real song purely through rhythm, phrasing and groove? The first structure was very simple: the first thirteen NATO alphabet words in verse one, the remaining thirteen in verse two, with a multilingual count from one to twelve as the chorus. I initially planned an English bridge to pull everything together, but that quickly proved unnecessary.
The first musical direction was much more overtly dance-oriented: around 120–124 BPM, with nu-disco, funky electropop, prominent brass and a choir. It worked mechanically, but I had already spent quite enough time in disco territory with Pasta Disco. More importantly, the vocals were too shouty. The song needed to make me move without sounding as though it was ordering me to.
The early versions exposed another problem. Short lyric lines encouraged Suno to turn the performance into call-and-response, interrupting the flow I wanted. Commas could cause little stops as well. I therefore removed punctuation, lengthened the phrasing and added small connecting lines such as Nothing more and nothing less. Some NATO words also needed phonetic nudges — In-dee-yah, Ju-li-ett, Lee-ma, Cu-bec, See-erra and Ex-ray — but I deliberately stopped correcting once the performance sounded convincing. Perfect pronunciation was less important than feel.
Version 3 showed that the rhythm was heading in the right direction, although there was still a slightly unwanted YMCA-like quality to the arrangement. Version 4 went completely off the rails: it lasted 7:59 and deteriorated into noise in its second half. That one made the next decision rather easy. I reduced the tempo dramatically, first towards 112 BPM and eventually to 70 BPM, and abandoned the disco approach in favour of warm, soulful swing.
The decisive change was the voice. I switched to a rich, low-register female lead, partly because a female voice had worked so well on The Point of Penguins. The production brief became much more organic: live drums, deep bass guitar, clean rhythm guitar, subtle electric piano, light percussion and brass used for colour rather than force. I wanted the atmosphere of an elegant old nightclub — loose, sophisticated and playful — with continuous momentum and no instrumental sections that emptied the dance floor.
That reset changed everything. By version 8, the musicians seemed to be enjoying themselves rather than executing instructions. Version 7 may have been technically tidier, but it swung a few degrees less, and that was enough. Version 8 was the one.
The useful lesson from Alphabet Soup was that technical improvement and musical improvement are not always the same thing: once a track makes me sit in my chair swinging with a ridiculous grin on my face, knowing when to stop is part of making the song.